Last week was one of my heavier weeks as far as herd checks
go. I had herd checks on 10 different farms, a few DAs to do, a few other sick
cows to look at and a couple of sick calves. It was a pretty routine week for
me, but as I was considering what to write about this week, I realized that
most of the farms I was on this week, would be considered “Factory Farms” in
the general public’s eyes. This is the
most frequently used and most flawed description of agriculture I have yet to
come across in over 30 years of being in agriculture.
Just to see what is out there, I googled “What is a factory
farm?” The first hit was a very popular Animal Rights website. This is a direct quote:
“A factory farm is a large, industrial operation that
raises large numbers of animals for food. Over 99% of farm animals in the U.S.
are raised in factory farms, which focus on profit and efficiency at the
expense of the animals’ welfare. “
So my question is as it relates to the dairy industry:
what is considered large???? 100 cows? 1000? 5000? 10,000? Every single client
of mine, whether they milk 50 cows or 2000 cows, is owned, operated and
managed by one family. So when people use the term “Factory Farm,” realize you
are most likely talking about a “Family Farm.”
Website: “Factory farms pack animals into spaces so tight
that most can barely move. Many have no access to the outdoors, spending their
lives on open warehouse floors, or housed in cages or pens. Without the room to
engage in natural behaviors, confined animals experience severe physical and
mental distress.”
|
Stalls with deep sand for ample cushioning |
I’m not sure how many freestall barns members of this animal
rights organization have been in, but I’m in them every day of the week, pretty
much all day long. Cows that live in
barns do spend time on concrete. Many farms put rubber mats down in areas where
cows spend the most time, so that they do have cushioning, while standing. The stalls that are
in the barn are specifically designed by agriculture engineers to best fit the
cows that are in them. They are lined with mattresses (some even have water beds) or deep sand. Cows have ample space in the stalls to stretch out and
sleep comfortably. If a cow gets hungry, she can get up and walk over to the
feed bunk where a completely balanced meal is sitting there ready to eat,
whenever she wants it. The alleys in
these barns provide ample room for cows to meander about and perform natural
socialization behaviors.
|
A mountain of fresh, nutritionally balanced food deliverd daily. |
|
Curtains that rise and lower based on outside temps |
Many freestall barns have curtains on the outside of the
barn that are raised up and lowered, automatically, based on the temperature
outside. Cows are protected from the snow, rain, wind and scorching sun with
these curtains. Many farms even have fans and sprinklers in the barns to try to
keep the cows as cool as possible during the summer. Cows that are too hot or too cold are
stressed. When cows are stressed, they don’t make milk. It is
counter-productive for a farmer, to not have their cows as comfortable as
possible, ALL THE TIME!
|
Fans to keep cows cool during hot summer days |
According to this animal rights organization, there are
several “Standard Factory Farming Practices.”
The statements in red are direct quotes from their website. The
statements in black are the truths about agriculture from someone who lives,
works and breathes it every day.
Unclean air: Waste piles up in the animal sheds, creating ammonia and dust. The ammonia
irritates and can even burn animals’ eyes, skin and throats.
TRUTH: Large farms use alley scrapers, which act as a
squeegee cleaning the manure. These scrapers run continuously so the cows are
rarely walking in their own waste. Farms that do not have alley scrapers use a
tractor to clean the barn every time the cows are out of their pen and at the
milking parlor. This is 2-3 times a day! Also, when the cows are out of their pen,
someone is cleaning, scraping and freshening up the stalls in the pen so that
when the cows come back from the parlor, they have a clean place to lie
down. They get completely new bedding at
least once a week and sometimes up to 3 times a week. Do you wash your sheets 3
times a week???
Unnatural lighting: Factory farms simulate unnatural day lengths to promote
fast growth and desired behaviors.
TRUTH: There are several studies that have shown that
when milking cows have longer
lighting periods (16 hours of light vs. 13), they will spend more time eating
and will produce about 8% more milk than with less lighting. It also provides a safer environment for the
people handling the cows, and the cows themselves. If you think about it, you yourself spend
16-18 hours a day with “unnatural light” and are sleeping in darkness for 6-8
hours. How is this different???
Unnatural growth: Fast and disproportionate growth and production due to selective breeding
causes ailments including chronic pain, mobility problems and heart problems.
TRUTH: Dairy cows reach maturity much faster than humans.
So yeah, they do grow fast. So do dogs and cats. Dairy cows and heifers have
their very own nutritionist that plans and evaluates their meals on a weekly to
monthly basis ensuring that animals have a completely balanced meal, with every
bite. Let’s think about this logically…
if cows are in chronic pain, are sick, uncomfortable or stressed are they going
to be able to perform at their best??? No. Again, it’s counter-productive!
Non-therapeutic medicating: So that they can survive the filthy conditions and grow
even faster, some industries feed their animals antibiotics and/or hormones.
TRUTH: Cows are not fed hormones and antibiotics to grow
faster. Monensin is the common culprit in this statement. This is a feed
additive that boosts the metabolism of the animal to better utilize the food
they are eating. A property of this feed additive is that it does have the
ability to help slow the growth of coccidia (a parasite found in the environment) in
animals. Because of this added bonus, it is often fed to younger animals as
part of their complete diet. Garlic is a food that humans often eat that has
additional benefits, such as “antibiotic” properties to it. Does that mean if
you are eating garlic you are “non-therapeutically medicating” yourself????
Unnatural reproduction: Many female farm animals spend virtually their entire
lives pregnant, putting them under chronic strain.
TRUTH: I’ve
discussed this before in a previous post. Cows are mammals. In order to produce
milk, they have to have a baby. If they
don’t have a baby, they stop making milk, get fat, have other metabolic issues
and are no longer productive animals. So
yes, mature cows do have a baby every year.
Heifers don’t get pregnant until they are of a mature size and their
uterus is sexually mature and ready to have a baby. It’s nature. Even if
animals weren’t in confinement, they would still have a baby every year.
Absent veterinary care: Most factory farms deny animals individualized
veterinary care, including humane euthanasia.
TRUTH: Now this statement is just ridiculous. I am on
these farms every week, for at LEAST an hour a day, if not up to 4-5 hours a
day. As a veterinarian, I am trained to be observant. My patients can’t talk to
me and tell me what’s wrong. As I walk through the barn every week, I have to
pick up on subtle clues to see that something is wrong. Large farms also have a staff that
specializes in cattle care. These employees spend all day, every day working
with these cows, examining them and treating them as needed. If their sickness
requires veterinary attention, I am called and am on the farm within hours to
attend to the sick animal. Some farms that are larger than the farms that I go
to, even have a veterinarian on staff, that is on site every day, taking care
of issues and sick animals on the farm.
As far as the euthanasia goes, there are several methods
of approved humane euthanasia techniques as described by the American
Veterinary Medical Association. Attached is the link to these methods, feel
free to read them and realize that these methods are very commonly used on large
farms. Euthanasia Guidelines
Surgical mutilations: Many farm animals undergo painful mutilations to their
tails, testicles, horns, toes or beaks, without painkillers, to make their
behavior more manageable.
TRUTH: I’ve also written about this in previous posts.
For the most part, cows do get pain medication when certain procedures are
being performed. Other procedures listed, really aren’t painful procedures, and
feel more like you are cutting your fingernails, not performing surgery. This
is an area that the agriculture industry continues to try to improve on. Most
of which, is training employees of the farm, the techniques to use, so that
pain mitigation is achieved. I can
assure you that none of these procedures are done with malicious intent. There
is still plenty of room for improvement, but progress is being made every day
to ensure that cows really are pain free.
Shortened lives: Factory farmed animals are generally slaughtered at “market weight” well
before the end of their natural life spans. In fact, most are still babies.
TRUTH: This applies more to the pig and chicken industry
of which I am not practiced in. I encourage you to find resources from the
American Association of Swine Veterinarians, and the American College of
Poultry Veterinarians. There is
relevance to the beef industry where steers are fed to market weight and then
slaughtered for beef. This is part of
the food chain. This is the purpose that farm animals serve and have served for
thousands of years.
Just like there are bad lawyers and bad doctors, there are some bad farmers. I won't deny that. There are advantages and disadvantages to the 50 cow farm and the 5000 cow farm. I visit many farms that I am proud to call my clients. They take wonderful care of their animals and are rewarded with healthy cows that make a lot of milk. The more people try to actually understand how a cow lives, what their needs are, and how hard farmers work to provide them these needs, the more ridiculous these ulterior-motive media outlets sound. Still have questions? Find a local farmer or large animal veterinarian and ask!!!